| Team | Pick | Name | Pos | Rating |
|---|
| Thunderbolts | 1 | Ryan Zack | D | 5 |
| Galaxies | 2 | Austin Chapman | F/D | 5 |
| Aerostars | 3 | Chet Putek | F/D | 5 |
| Marauders | 4 | Alex Cowart | F | 5 |
| Diesels | 5 | Riley Lenhard | F | 5 |
| Bullitts | 6 | Branden Rosen | F | 5 |
| SuperChiefs | 7 | Adam Gorski Jr | F/D | 5 |
| Cobras | 8 | Chris Deroche | D | 5 |
| Mustangs | 9 | Joseph Zalewski | F/D | 5 |
| Mariners | 10 | Ryan Pearson | F/D | 5 |
| Edsels | 11 | Timmy Lyons | F/D | 4.5 |
| Fiesta | 12 | Tom LeFevre | D/F | 4.5 |
| Thunderbolts | 13 | Daniel Middleton | F/D | 4.5 |
| Galaxies | 14 | Rocco Matera | F | 4.5 |
| Aerostars | 15 | Geoff Seeley | D | 4.5 |
| SuperChiefs | 16 | Blake Smith | F/D | 4.5 |
| Diesels | 17 | Jeff Donaldson | D/F | 4.5 |
| Bullitts | 18 | Travis Parent | D | 4.5 |
| Marauders | 19 | Gret Radomski | D | 4 |
| Cobras | 20 | Adam Pinkowski | D | 4 |
| Mustangs | 21 | Dany Beaupre | D | 4.5 |
| Mariners | 22 | Jordan Petravicius | F | 4.5 |
| Edsels | 23 | Rob Kalinski | F | 4 |
| Fiesta | 24 | Andrew Bazzy | F | 4 |
| Thunderbolts | 25 | Andrew Gates | F | 4 |
| Galaxies | 26 | Conner Cecott | F | 4 |
| Aerostars | 27 | Easton Rea | F | 4 |
| SuperChiefs | 28 | Shane Bryans | F/D | 4 |
| Diesels | 29 | Aaron Davis | F/D | 4 |
| Bullitts | 30 | Eric Peters | F/D | 4 |
| Marauders | 31 | Chris Robillard | F | 4 |
| Cobras | 32 | Vincent Ceccarelli | F | 4 |
| Mustangs | 33 | Kevin Robson | F/D | 4 |
| Mariners | 34 | Zach Grifka | D | 4 |
| Edsels | 35 | Dave Bartkowiak | F | 3.5 |
| Fiesta | 36 | Dustin Jones | D | 4 |
| Thunderbolts | 37 | Tim Alderman | F | 4 |
| Galaxies | 38 | Michael Barta jr | F | 4 |
| Aerostars | 39 | Roderic Dolega | F | 4 |
| SuperChiefs | 40 | Doug Sparks | D | 4 |
| Diesels | 41 | Jack Thomas | F | 3.5 |
| Bullitts | 42 | William Girard | F | 3.5 |
| Marauders | 43 | Dan Radomski | F | 3.5 |
| Cobras | 44 | John Durst | D | 3.5 |
| Mustangs | 45 | Anthony Batalucco | F/D | 3.5 |
| Mariners | 46 | Steve Harris | F/D | 3.5 |
| Edsels | 47 | Steve Upplegger | D | 3.5 |
| Fiesta | 48 | Richard Lauth | F | 3.5 |
| Thunderbolts | 49 | Owen Winkler | F/D | 3.5 |
| Galaxies | 50 | Matthew Schultz | D/F | 3.5 |
| Aerostars | 51 | John Crisi | F/D | 3.5 |
| SuperChiefs | 52 | Joe Spurlin | F/D | 3.5 |
| Diesels | 53 | Nico Deluca | F | 3.5 |
| Bullitts | 54 | Joseph Robillard | F | 3.5 |
| Marauders | 55 | Joe Korepta | D | 3.5 |
| Cobras | 56 | Jason Blair | F | 3.5 |
| Mustangs | 57 | Spencer Brainard | F/D | 3.5 |
| Mariners | 58 | Matt Kluegel | F/D | 3.5 |
| Edsels | 59 | Spencer Blatt | F/D | 3.5 |
| Fiesta | 60 | James Konstantino | F/D | 3.5 |
| Thunderbolts | 61 | Andrew Hinkle | D | 3.5 |
| Galaxies | 62 | Curtis Clark | D | 3.5 |
| Aerostars | 63 | Matt Springer | D | 3.5 |
| SuperChiefs | 64 | Kevin Walker | F | 3.5 |
| Diesels | 65 | Nathan Radl | F | 3 |
| Bullitts | 66 | Tom Bordeau | F | 3 |
| Marauders | 67 | Terry Johnson | F | 3 |
| Cobras | 68 | Matt Margitan | F/D | 3 |
| Mustangs | 69 | William Aben | F/D | 3 |
| Mariners | 70 | Ryan Jones | F | 3 |
| Edsels | 71 | Eric Chase | F | 3 |
| Fiesta | 72 | Jason Sladich | D/F | 3.5 |
| Thunderbolts | 73 | Rob Hall | F/D | 3 |
| Galaxies | 74 | Thomas Filar | D | 3 |
| Aerostars | 75 | Cameron Schmidt | D/F | 3 |
| SuperChiefs | 76 | Charlie Tyson | F | 3.5 |
| Diesels | 77 | Ruben Jasso | F | 3 |
| Bullitts | 78 | Christopher Colarusso | F/D | 3 |
| Marauders | 79 | Ryan Halloran | F | 3 |
| Cobras | 80 | Blair Jenness | F | 3 |
| Mustangs | 81 | Patrick Coliton | D/F | 3 |
| Mariners | 82 | Andrew Daehn | F/D | 3 |
| Edsels | 83 | Jenna Dancewicz | F | 3 |
| Fiesta | 84 | Spencer Hoernke | F/D | 3 |
| Thunderbolts | 85 | Kyle Skillman | F/D | 3 |
| Galaxies | 86 | Dan Vincent | F | 2.5 |
| Aerostars | 87 | Christopher Caron | F/D | 2.5 |
| SuperChiefs | 88 | David McLean | F | 2.5 |
| Diesels | 89 | Brad Hajec | D | 2.5 |
| Bullitts | 90 | Ed Rose | F/D | 2.5 |
| Marauders | 91 | Todd Soper | F | 2.5 |
| Cobras | 92 | Brent LHeureux | D | 2.5 |
| Mustangs | 93 | Victor Quattrin | F/D | 2 |
| Mariners | 94 | John Pearson | F | 2.5 |
| Edsels | 95 | Ron Martina | F/D | 2.5 |
| Fiesta | 96 | Bob Jones | F | 2.5 |
| Galaxies | 97 | Bryan Sauve | F | 2 |
| Aerostars | 98 | Phil Rea | F | 2 |
| SuperChiefs | 99 | Pat DiMarco | F | 2.5 |
| Thunderbolts | 100 | Geoffrey Middleton | F/D | 2 |
| Mariners | 101 | Michael Pawlukiewicz | D | 2 |
| Diesels | 102 | John Lubig | F | 2 |
| Marauders | 103 | Mark Heikkila | F/D | 2 |
| Cobras | 104 | Dennis Koehler | F/D | 1.5 |
| Mustangs | 105 | Jim Tassis | F/D | 1 |
| Bullitts | 106 | Dave Born | F | 1.5 |
| Edsels | 107 | Ken Kasper | F | 2 |
| Fiesta | 108 | Chuck Ginman | F/D | 1 |